Technical Team/Minutes/2015-06-09

From SPDX Wiki
Jump to: navigation, search

June 9, 2015

Attendees

  • Gary O'Neall
  • Scott Sterling
  • Bill Schineller
  • Kirsten Newcomer
  • Kate Stewart
  • Hassib Khanafer
  • Michael Herzog

Snippets

  • Draft proposal from Kate (https://docs.google.com/document/d/13OknzNnY56UZhnj_VVPatirBrNze5cWXDx2fnKbBI_g)
  • Should we support snippets in an SPDX document that refer to files contained outside the SPDX document?
    • Downstream edits of SPDX document use cases - probably good to have copy of the file
    • Since it always have to refer back to a file, we should require a copy of the file
    • Leaning towards requiring the file to be present in the same doc for a snippet
  • Name is not required
    • Requires a change to the model
    • Could we make in optional?
      • Can we distinguish that in RDF
    • Would need to update tools
    • Snippet naming left open, use a proposal
      • Need a proposal on how the name would be proposed
      • Could be nothing, optional or mandatory
      • jQuery UI use case - "button" is generated
  • Discussion on including snippets for files not included in the SPDX document
    • Needs to be present in some SPDX document - may require adding the file to the SPDX Document
    • Need to document the requirement
  • Line numbers - left open - pick up conversation

Review SPDX Identifier wiki page

  • Inconsistent use of ID and Identifier - Agreed to make it consistent using Identifier since that is being used primarily by the early adopters.