THE SPDX WIKI IS NO LONGER ACTIVE. ALL CONTENT HAS BEEN MOVED TO https://github.com/spdx
Difference between revisions of "Technical Team/Minutes/2014-10-22"
From SPDX Wiki
< Technical Team | Minutes
(Created page with "November 14th: SPDX 2.0 Draft (RC1) Complete, distributed for internal review/comment (committees) December 1 - deadline for feedback Dec 1-17: incorporate feedback Dec 1...") |
|||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
| − | November 14th: SPDX 2.0 Draft (RC1) Complete, distributed for internal review/comment (committees) | + | October 21, 2014 |
| − | + | == Attendees == | |
| − | December 1 - deadline for feedback | + | * Gary O'Neall |
| − | + | * Bill Schineller | |
| − | Dec 1-17: incorporate feedback | + | * Kate Stewart |
| − | + | * Mark Gisi | |
| − | Dec 18: SPDX 2.0 Specification Release Candidate (RC2) For Tool Implementation (Public Review via general mailing list) | + | * Kirsten Newcomer |
| − | + | * Scott Sterling | |
| − | Dec 19th: Tool Implementation Kickoff | + | * Jack Manbeck |
| − | + | == Agenda == | |
| − | + | * License Expression Language | |
| − | Jan 15: SPDX 2.0 Specification Release Candidate (RC3) - Updates from Tool Impl Feedback | + | * File Tagging |
| − | + | * Schedule Update | |
| − | February 18-20, 2015: Linux Collab Summit, SPDX 2.0 Tools Bakeoff | + | == License Expression Language == |
| − | + | * Mark will email Kate the word doc with the current proposal | |
| − | + | * Kate will upload to a Google doc. for sharing | |
| + | == File Tagging == | ||
| + | * Reviewed Jack's proposal | ||
| + | * Agreed to the text for Jack's proposal | ||
| + | * Proposal to use the tags for more than just the license ID | ||
| + | ** Would imply a format that makes it easy to translate (e.g. SPDX.[tag]:) | ||
| + | ** Agreed not to change the tag name from SPDX-License-Id since it is already in use | ||
| + | ** In the future, we could extend and perhaps use SPDX- as the prefix | ||
| + | * Agreed to update the source files for the SPDX tools with the tags | ||
| + | ** Kate will do a pull request | ||
| + | * How to delimit the license ID's? | ||
| + | ** Parens are no longer required in the license expression | ||
| + | ** Also a problem in the tag/value | ||
| + | ** Several proposals | ||
| + | *** Use end of line to terminate | ||
| + | *** Use parenthesis to expressions beyond the single license IDs | ||
| + | *** Use <text> </text> tags | ||
| + | *** Use the end of comment | ||
| + | * Add suggestion to declare a string variable with the tag/value pair to include in the binaries | ||
| + | ** Some concern we may want to hold off for now | ||
| + | ** Agree to hold off for one week - will discuss next week | ||
| + | ==Schedule Update== | ||
| + | * November 14th: SPDX 2.0 Draft (RC1) Complete, distributed for internal review/comment (committees) | ||
| + | * December 1 - deadline for feedback | ||
| + | * Dec 1-17: incorporate feedback | ||
| + | * Dec 18: SPDX 2.0 Specification Release Candidate (RC2) For Tool Implementation (Public Review via general mailing list) | ||
| + | * Dec 19th: Tool Implementation Kickoff | ||
| + | * Jan 15: SPDX 2.0 Specification Release Candidate (RC3) - Updates from Tool Impl Feedback | ||
| + | * February 18-20, 2015: Linux Collab Summit, SPDX 2.0 Tools Bakeoff | ||
| + | ** compare SPDX 2.0 output of different tools for compatibility/consistency | ||
| + | ** supply chain example. Upstream SPDX consumed by downstream SPDX. | ||
| + | [[Category:Technical|Minutes]] | ||
| + | [[Category:Minutes]] | ||
Latest revision as of 16:44, 22 October 2014
October 21, 2014
Attendees
- Gary O'Neall
- Bill Schineller
- Kate Stewart
- Mark Gisi
- Kirsten Newcomer
- Scott Sterling
- Jack Manbeck
Agenda
- License Expression Language
- File Tagging
- Schedule Update
License Expression Language
- Mark will email Kate the word doc with the current proposal
- Kate will upload to a Google doc. for sharing
File Tagging
- Reviewed Jack's proposal
- Agreed to the text for Jack's proposal
- Proposal to use the tags for more than just the license ID
- Would imply a format that makes it easy to translate (e.g. SPDX.[tag]:)
- Agreed not to change the tag name from SPDX-License-Id since it is already in use
- In the future, we could extend and perhaps use SPDX- as the prefix
- Agreed to update the source files for the SPDX tools with the tags
- Kate will do a pull request
- How to delimit the license ID's?
- Parens are no longer required in the license expression
- Also a problem in the tag/value
- Several proposals
- Use end of line to terminate
- Use parenthesis to expressions beyond the single license IDs
- Use <text> </text> tags
- Use the end of comment
- Add suggestion to declare a string variable with the tag/value pair to include in the binaries
- Some concern we may want to hold off for now
- Agree to hold off for one week - will discuss next week
Schedule Update
- November 14th: SPDX 2.0 Draft (RC1) Complete, distributed for internal review/comment (committees)
- December 1 - deadline for feedback
- Dec 1-17: incorporate feedback
- Dec 18: SPDX 2.0 Specification Release Candidate (RC2) For Tool Implementation (Public Review via general mailing list)
- Dec 19th: Tool Implementation Kickoff
- Jan 15: SPDX 2.0 Specification Release Candidate (RC3) - Updates from Tool Impl Feedback
- February 18-20, 2015: Linux Collab Summit, SPDX 2.0 Tools Bakeoff
- compare SPDX 2.0 output of different tools for compatibility/consistency
- supply chain example. Upstream SPDX consumed by downstream SPDX.
