Technical Team/Use Cases/2.0

We have several sources to begin pulling for SPDX Use Cases:

1. The Pad from earlier conversations collected at <a href="http://spdx.org/wiki/use-cases-collected-20-discussion">Use Cases For SPDX 2.0 Discussion</a>
2. The old <a href="https://fossbazaar.org/wiki/spdx-use-case-1">SPDX 1.0 Use Cases</a> as well as the <a href="http://spdx.org/system/files/ecosystem.jpg">SDPX 1.0 Use Case Picture</a>.

 

I'd like to propose that we flesh out use cases here by having a brief summary listed here as a link to a more detailed child page.   Note, these use cases should be *doable* but in general not *required*.  Any item listed here that is not a link, should have a child page created for it.

 

1. Code contributors
1. <a href="http://spdx.org/wiki/committers-provides-spdx-data-code-being-committed">Committer provides SPDX data</a>
2. Committer assents to SPDX data of upstream project
3. Committer annotates source files with SPDX data
4. Patch provider provides SPDX data
5. Patch provider assents to SPDX data of upstream project 
2. <a href="http://spdx.org/wiki/spdx-20-usecase-upstream-maintainer-providing-spdx-data">Upstream maintainer providing SPDX data</a>
1. <a href="http://spdx.org/wiki/upstream-maintainer-providing-spdx-data-source-archive">Upstream maintainer providing SPDX data in source archive</a>
2. <a href="http://spdx.org/wiki/upstream-maintainer-providing-spdx-data-scm">Upstream maintainer providing SPDX data in SCM</a>
3. Upstream maintainer consuming another project
1. Upstream maintainer including another project by including source
2. Upstream maintainer including another project by reference (think maven, possibly linking cases)
1. by static reference (the referenced library is included with a redistribution)
2. by dynamic reference (express runtime dependency on the external library, but not redistributing it)
3. Upstream maintainer pulling individual files out of another project (subsetting)
4. Intermediate packager (rpm, deb, etc) passing on and adding to SPDX Data
1. Intermediate packager builds source package from upstream source
1. <a href="http://spdx.org/wiki/intermediate-packager-builds-source-package-upstream-source-provides-spdx-data">Intermediate packager builds source package from upstream source that provides SPDX data</a>
2. Intermediate packager builds source package from upstream source that does not provide SPDX data
2. Intermediate packager builds binary package from upstream source
1. <a href="http://spdx.org/wiki/intermediate-packager-builds-binary-package-upstream-source-provides-spdx-data">Intermediate packager builds binary package from upstream source that provides SPDX data</a>
2. Intermediate packager builds binary package from upstream source that does not provides SPDX data
3. Intermediate packager adds patches to upstream source 
1. <a href="http://spdx.org/wiki/intermediate-packager-adds-patches-upstream-source-provides-spdx-data">Intermediate packager adds patches to upstream source that provides SPDX data</a>
2. Intermediate packager adds patches to upstream source that does not provide SPDX data
4. Intermediate packager adds someone else's patches to upstream source
1. <a href="http://spdx.org/wiki/intermediate-packager-adds-someone-elses-patches-upstream-source-provides-spdx-data">Intermediate packager adds someone else's patches to upstream source that provides SPDX data</a>
2. Intermediate packager adds someone else's patches to upstream source that does not provide SPDX data
5. Intermediate packager subsetting upstream source
1. <a href="http://spdx.org/wiki/intermediate-packager-subsetting-upstream-source-provides-spdx-data">Intermediate packager subsetting upstream source that provides SPDX data</a>
2. Intermediate packager subsetting upstream source that does not provide SPDX data
5. Yocto [Jack Manbeck]
6. Aggregator aggregating many 'copyrightable items' for redistribution
1. Linux Distros [Kate Stewart]
2. Embedded Images
3. SDKs
4. <a href="http://spdx.org/wiki/spdx-20-usecase-reference-implementations">Reference implementations </a>[Jack Manbeck]
5. Eclipse/OSGI distributions
6. <a href="http://spdx.org/wiki/spdx-20-usecase-application-which-ships-documentation-media-software">Application which ships with documentation +  media + software</a> [Jack Manbeck]
7. <a title="Use case details" href="http://spdx.org/wiki/application-which-ships-contrib-libraries">Application which ships with a contrib libraries</a> [Gary O'Neall]
8. <a title="Use case details" href="http://spdx.org/wiki/application-which-ships-development-tools">Application which ships with development tools</a> [Gary O'Neall]
7. Aggregators aggregating other aggergations for redistribution
8. Asserting corrections to SPDX data provided by others further upstream
9. Consumers receiving SPDX data
10. Signoff/multiple signoff on SPDX data
1. Contracts with multiple parties requiring signoff by all [Kate Stewart]
11. Auditor scenario: given big pile of 'copyrightable items', creating Bill of Materials [Peter Williams]
12. Sanity-checking Bill of Material
1. outbound: validate that SPDX goes hand in hand with what's being shipped [Kirsten Newcomer]
2. inbound:  validate that SPDX goes hand in hand with what's being brought in 
13. Java complications [Richard Fontana]

 

Cross-cutting concerns:

1. Provenance (the need to optionally use signing to validate who said what)
2. Handling staleness of data
3. Expressing applicable licensing as a function of Usage [Bill Schineller]
4. Permissive licensed thing becomes restrictive as function of packaging (e.g. BSD file included in GPL becomes GPL)

 

Themes:

 

Looking at these Use Cases, there are some underlying themes:

1. Root of data (closer to upstream the better)
2. Subsetting of copyrightable things (and their SPDX data) (Note: Subsets of copyrightable things are usually also copyrightable things)
3. Aggregation of copyrightable things (and their SPDX data) (Note: Aggregations of copyrightable things are usually also copyrightable things).