Skip to content

Legal Team/Minutes/2017-06-22

Archived page

Read-only copy of the SPDX wiki. The wiki is no longer active; its content has moved to https://github.com/spdx. Last edited 2017-07-05 by Jlovejoy.

Attendees

  • Brad Edmondson
  • Paul Madick
  • Alexios Zavras
  • Michael Herzog
  • Mike Dolan
  • Karen Copenhaver
  • Gary O'Neall
  • Jilayne Lovejoy
  • Alan Tse

Agenda

1) XML Update: website preview:

  • ~30 licenses had issues - need to address when cleaned up - some just out of order, etc.
  • some had to do with lists that didn't have items or missing end list tag
  • tag for other URLs: if that is empty it throws an error - if no URL, then remove that tag/section altogether --> after conversion, Gary can fix and commit directly.
  • landing page with table - looks the same, no changes
  • individual pages: (Apache-2.0 as example)
  • bullets/numbers are showing up on a separate line. after we convert, do a global search and replace and remove p tag around bullet tag - should then display correctly - will want to review after that to make sure it didn't break it otherwise
  • colored text for replaceable and omitable text (red and blue) displaying same for red text, but blue is not showing up - should trigger off of optional tag
  • process:

  • still need to review ~20 licenses

  • address any remaining issues
  • freeze!! XML repository (change settings to only a few people have direct commit access)
  • in XML repository: new tag conversion (to new names)
  • address any issues related to generating webpage (Gary or will file new issue)
  • generate web pages to PREVIEW
  • resolve any issues
  • go live!

  • need to sort out how to replace old repository with XML repository...

  • put note on old one and refer to new one and just use that
  • rename? have to sort out how that would work. maybe just rename current one to "archive" and keep XML repo name as is
  • OR clone XML into current repo, then get rid of XML repo --> this seems like better option
  • then update other webpages:
  • move matching guidelines into Github too, so can be tracked for changes, etc.
  • process requesting a new license and tracking that (in Github, in spreadsheet, etc.)
  • XML description Schema? (add link to that... where?)
  • general instructions on contributing to the license list - on Github README (with link to that from website / license list page)

2) Request to add Linux Normal System Call Note to SPDX License List

  • is this an exception? this is where it structurally belongs re: the SPDX License List
  • acknowedgment that "exception" concept language, was not well-formed at the time Linus put this note with the license. it is with the license, part of license, not just some random info somewhere else
  • what about extra paragraph re: GPL only as found here? https://github.com/torvalds/linux/blame/master/COPYING
  • Karen and Mike to go back to kernel folks to ask about this variation