Jlovejoy at 14:22, 12 August 2020

2020-08-12T14:22:11Z

Goneall: Created page with "August 11, 2020 == Attendees == * Kate Stewart * Thomas Steenbergen * Steve Winslow * Jilayne Lovejoy * Steve Winslow * Gary O’Neall * Rose Judge * Peter Shin * Brad Goldri..."

2020-08-11T21:43:41Z

Created page with "August 11, 2020 == Attendees == * Kate Stewart * Thomas Steenbergen * Steve Winslow * Jilayne Lovejoy * Steve Winslow * Gary O’Neall * Rose Judge * Peter Shin * Brad Goldri..."

New page

August 11, 2020
== Attendees ==
* Kate Stewart
* Thomas Steenbergen
* Steve Winslow
* Jilayne Lovejoy
* Steve Winslow
* Gary O’Neall
* Rose Judge
* Peter Shin
* Brad Goldring
* John Horan
* Rose Judge
* Vicky Brasseur
* William Bartolomew
* Mark Atwood

Topics:
* Legal profile

==Legal Profile==
* Work being done in Google Docs https://docs.google.com/document/d/1k_2tSlFXvW_SbW-I1DcSEoCNBMQJd4FEFIQr6KCJuyU/edit#
* Tried to keep section numbers same
* Note: Has not been reviewed by the entire legal team – will review in upcoming legal team meeting
* Normalized naming (e.g. references to Spdx Document rather than Spdx File)
* Discussion on Declared License for Package – metadata
** Thomas raised question on if the Artifact includes the metadata or if it is different
** Discussion on the previous discussions
*** Maven POM files was discussed previously and general agreement that the POM license info would be declared but not concluded
*** POM file license information was not always accurate
** Different scenarios discussed, general agreement that a binary distribution would be a different artifact from the bundle of source
* Discussion on license information that is not completely in the file (e.g. jQuery which includes a link but not the license notice)
** Some tools will fill in the actual license referred to
* Should we document the examples for Declared and Concluded licenses?
** Valuable information
** More specific would be better, but would make it larger
*** Would be nice to have some additional documentation somewhere
** Generally agree to move from the specific fields to the intro for the section
* Discussion on None field for license
** Should the field be renamed NONE_FOUND?
*** Concern it would break tools
** General agreement that NONE means someone looked really hard for a license and couldn’t find one at all
** In the case of “No Rights Reserved”, one would create a LicenseRef-
* Discussion cookbook
** Could create hover over in the spec
*** Concern about accessibility
* Replacing references to Disjunctive license with “OR”
* Continue discussion on the Legal team this Thursday
* What is the name of the profile for licensing?
** “Licensing”
* Discussion on associating copyright owner with license
** Thomas has a requirement to associate the license with the copyright owners
** Current SPDX does not have a mechanism to retain the associations
** Could use snippets to retain the association between copyright owners and licenses for specific code

[[Category:Technical|Minutes]]

@@ Line 17: / Line 17: @@
 Topics:
-* Legal profile
+* Licensing profile - consolidation of license fields
 ==Legal Profile==
-* Work being done in Google Docs https://docs.google.com/document/d/1k_2tSlFXvW_SbW-I1DcSEoCNBMQJd4FEFIQr6KCJuyU/edit#
+* Initial draft by Steve and Jilayne in Google Docs https://docs.google.com/document/d/1k_2tSlFXvW_SbW-I1DcSEoCNBMQJd4FEFIQr6KCJuyU/edit#
-* Tried to keep section numbers same
+* Note: didn't really update section numbers
 * Note: Has not been reviewed by the entire legal team – will review in upcoming legal team meeting
-* Normalized naming (e.g. references to Spdx Document rather than Spdx File)
+* Normalized naming (e.g. references to Spdx Document rather than Spdx File) - this needs to be done across spec
 * Discussion on Declared License for Package – metadata
 ** Thomas raised question on if the Artifact includes the metadata or if it is different

Technical Team/Minutes/2020-08-11 - Revision history

Jlovejoy at 14:22, 12 August 2020

Goneall: Created page with "August 11, 2020 == Attendees == * Kate Stewart * Thomas Steenbergen * Steve Winslow * Jilayne Lovejoy * Steve Winslow * Gary O’Neall * Rose Judge * Peter Shin * Brad Goldri..."